Celestino's New York Pizza

Love this place! Not only is it great pizza that is unique and well made but it doesn't cost an arm and a leg for quality food. The staff is beyond nice and always on point. Get the Tom Jones and godfather pizza. Both are great but if you can only get one I say the godfather. The calzones are off the charts as well. Crispy and filled with cheese but don't get that pocket of grease some calzones get.

Really great pies, they deserve five stars for the quality of the pizzas. Great place to go if you want to get 1 or 2 slices. They just lose one star for the unfriendly staff members. Sometimes you walk in there and none of them give you a smile or hello. But that’s this the way college students are now days it’s not really the restaurants fault.

It's amazing although it can get pretty crowded around lunch hours I guess it just proves how good it is, but due to it being crowded they don't always get to things so quickly, yet again there are a lot of people. As for my overall outlook I absolutely love it. I am able to sit in a comfortable environment and enjoy a meal with my friends and or family.

I gave 4 stars for the pizza which was excellent, but the service was not. Rude and would not address my issue which was prices online was almost 5 dollars cheaper than inside the parlor. when asked why ? they brushed me off like it didn't matter and did not fix or compensate in any way..as much as I love this pizza I won't return or suggest too anyone else ..

I cannot
seem to delete this message but, as I was editing the owner did reach out to apologize and offer a discount on my next order. So thank you Enzo that meant a lot ..

A standard classic of every Chico State student. Perfect place to meet with your club or other group. The pizza is amazing and ready super quick. Great deal, great place, great atmosphere.