Original Antonio's Pizza - Deli

I had the Mexican spaghetti which was delicious. I'm going to make it at home from now on. Mallory was our waitress and she was awesome. 👍

Loved the atmosphere. Service was good. Small enough inside that he was never far away. The garlic bread was heavenly. Honestly, we could have eaten just that! Also, we got a side of alfredo pasta for the non-pizza eater in the group, and it was also yummy. We planned to have leftovers of the pizza for the next meal, but it was so good we ate it all then and there. We also felt it was reasonably priced

We tried the cheese pizza and honestly our pizza slices was cold the cheese was har
Wish it was fresh off the oven but it tasted like it sat there for hours

I get that you are located on an island and the choices are limited - but this was really not great. Unfortunately you start off on a bad foot ordering from the window. Just an angry and yelling employee greeting everyone who walks up with a scowl. Lots of rules and signs posted near the window should have keyed us in to the vibe. Pizza itself is very mediocre and way overpriced for the 7-11 hot case quality you will get.

A great little funky spot. The food we had was great for this style of venue. The service was friendly and the food was prepared in a timely manner. All-in-all a great experience. Better than many of the other restaurants on the island. Certainly worth a visit, especially if you love pizza. The peanuts were a nice addition as well.