Good Fellas Pizza

Best pizza in Whittier. I grew up in Whittier and I have eaten Pizzamania and Joe peeps Pizza all my life. But Good Fellas takes it. My son and I love it. Always fresh and tastes amazing.

Chill vibes. Isley Brothers and other classic hits in that genre were playing in the background. Lots of Mafia movie references as decor. Cashier was super friendly. Owners seem nice and made sure my food was good. Meatball Sub has a well seasoned Meatball. Well toasted bread. Soft exterior. I believe the crust of pizza is brushed with garlic and butter. Nice mozzarella pull and the pepperoni has a nice kick. Sauce is a bit tangy. Quite different than what I am used to. Fries were pretty standard. They could have been seasoned more. Diet Coke/Coca-Cola is as best as it can be. A slice and a drink is $5 and a Meatball Sub is $7.99 before tax. Could be tough to find parking.

02/01/24: I’m still giving it a four star review. I’ve noticed they did not butter the crust with garlic on my slices. They also gave me a smaller size drink cup.

The pizza here is delicious! The cheese, crust, pepperoni everything. Plus they have a by the slice special with a medium drink for $5.00. Inside is a bit small so it best for a small party of 2 to 4 at a table.

I’m gonna start off by saying this is the best pizza in Whittier, hands-down. Now I understand they will be a lot of naysayers, but their pizza has pepperoni cups! There is not another pizzeria in Whittier that can say this. Trust me on this I am an expert. From the photo, you will see, I have them add a sprinkle of cold cheese on top to minimize the mouth roof burn. $5 Lunch for the Win!