The Cookie Plug

12/9/2023

Very cool vibe and staff was super nice. I just got two cookies, which are large, and both are tasty: Nutty OG and snicker doodle. They are about $5 pretty cookie. I would like to try the ice cream sandwich but they were out of ice cream today.

It was my first time trying it and the cashier recommended getting the 12 for $12 bundle so that I could try all the cookie flavors. It was a great idea. They were all so yummy and I loved the containers they use.

It was my first time in California and if you haven’t been to the Cookie Plug…. You are truly missing out! My word, they have an excellent selection of large cookies and I home took a few packs of the also soft and delicious miniature versions of the cookies.

Thereafter I greatly enjoyed the mini Cookies back home in Chicago, I kept the nifty tubes they came in just because of the fire aesthetic!

The Cookie Plug is a low key (it’s kinda hidden under another store, but you’ll see the signs don’t give up if you’re headed there) 5 Star hidden Gem of a Cookie Shop.

They even sell purple dyed 2% milk in a double cup here ! Haha it’s a VIBE, I went randomly and I’ll definitely be back if I’m in Anaheim again, 100% Recommended!

Who doesn't love a deep dish cookie? OMG! These are to DIE for! I was picking up my bathroom tile from the Mile of Tile store and struck up a conversation with the receptionist about cookies. She mentioned there was a cookie store nearby but she hadn't tried it. I Googled it and it was 1/2 a mile away! Score!

Picked up 12 cookies for $27 (special they were having) so i grabbed 4 chocolate chip (one for each of us) then grabbed 2 of some other flavors so we could each try half.

Chocolate chip was the bomb. It was SO rich it took me about 2 hours to eat. I definitely needed milk.

Chocolate chocolate was another house favorite. I love snickerdoodle so I'm pretty sure I forgot to share that. The sprinkled one is still sitting in the box. Nobody wanted to eat it. Oh well. I also picked up a seasonal pumpkin cream cookie. I happen to like these so I ate one and shared the other.

I will definitely go back and try their other flavors, like Smores, Purple Haze (purple velvet cookies) and Cookies and Cream. Their Purple Milk seems interesting, too.

The staff was very friendly and helpful. I missed the turn for parking so I parked in the BofA parking lot. Oopsie. Best to park in their lot .

Enjoy!

we luckily came on an afternoon where they weren't too busy but i'm sure this place can get packed with people. i was really pleased with the flavor on the 'peanut butter' cookie because it wasn't overwhelming as if you had a mouth full of peanut butter. the funfetti was also really good and they were really soft even 24 hours after the purchase. i'll be coming back to try more flavors and maybe one of their ice cream sandwiches which looked good on the menu.