Jimmy's Jersey Street Cafe

Hidden gem in Mayfair. The staff was welcoming in this cozy, classy spot. I had one of the best meals I have had in a long time with spectacular service. They have a huge selection, and I imagine everything is great. The other patrons seemed pleased as well. I can't say enough about the friendliness and professionalism of the staff! Thank you!

Enjoyed lunch here with two friends. Everyone meal was very good. I had the chicken ciabatta sandwich and it was perfect. The service was exceptional! I’m looking forward to returning.

I live in Historic Montclair, and a neighbor, who had never been to Jimmy's - I was a huge fan - decided to go have cocktails and appetizers on Saturday night around 6:30pm. He made reservations - and Veronica greeted us at the door, sat us at the perfect table and was our server. Her energy, knowledge of the menu - and especially, her skills in making us the perfect Manhattan really made this evening so special. The food can't be beat, good prices, and atmosphere takes you to Italy in this cozy room. Wine, food, service - Good job Jimmy! We will be back! And give Veronica a big hug from us!! We asked her to take her mask off for the photo, but the entire restaurant is CDC compliant.

I eat here often with friends for lunch and dinner. My husband loves it too. Such a great addition to the neighborhood. Super nice and attentive staff, the food is wonderful and so is the wine! Thanks Jimmy!

Just had dinner here for the first time on Friday night - They were very accommodating when we changed our reservation from 4 to 6 to 8 at the last minute. Fabulous covered patio kept us dry during a downpour. Wait staff was attentive and food was delicious. The owner came by to check on us. Will definitely be one of my go-to neighborhood spots!