Arthur Ave Pizza & Catering

Excellent Florentine pie (add sausage!). Meatball parm grinder is a sloppy, delicious mess, and I'd much prefer this to the typically too-bready, not saucy enough versions from most Italian places around here. The plain cheese was nothing to write home about, but it was certainly devoured in good measure. Highly recommended. I'll be back.

I don't know why I waited so long to try this. This is excellent pizza. The crust is fantastic. This is easily as good as any other pizza in Fairfield. I got the pepperoni, but am looking forward to trying some of the more interesting menu options. They also have grinders, calzones, pastas, and a pretty wide array of entrees (chicken, veal, beef, etc.).

The woman I interacted with at the counter was very nice, too. I'll definitely be returning.

Note - the restaurant itself has relatively little seating, maybe a couple tables and a small counter with stools. If your intention is to eat there, you might want to call ahead.

Wow. I lived in NYC eating pizza in the boroughs and now for many years live in Europe and have some favorites in small, rough towns around Naples where pizza is life. This was really so surprising and one of my best pizzas I've ever eaten there or stateside. the guy working it made this fresh tomato and peperoni pie in 15 minutes and the price was so reasonable. My brother and I were driving through and got it for take out and we ended up fighting over eating the whole thing in the car just outside it. I would definitely come here 1st choice for apizz and never again to places I've eaten before in new haven!!

Full of flavor without the grease or guilt. Best pizza I've had since I moved here 18 years ago. Worth the cheat if you're on a protein diet!

First off, I grew up in the NYC, and it is very difficult to find great pizza in ct.. until now!! I ordered the clams casino pizza and it was out of this world. Fresh clams, flavorful combo with bacon and peppers; delicious. Then I tried the chicken cutlet grinder, which was very filling and tasty. The owners were friendly and personable. I Highly recommend this place!