Trattoria Amalfi

Love this place !!!
We had lunch on Saturday fall day. Amazing menu, great atmosphere and felling like you are in Italy with every dish and drink.
Oysters were fresh to the point that we needed to order more and more.
Highly recommended and we, definitely, return there, when in town…
It just couldn’t be better.

This was our first time at this restaurant and we were pleasantly surprised. Our waiter, Josh, was superb and extremely knowledgeable. He guided us through all our food choices for this excellent dinning experience. We started with appetizers: Crispy Meatballs stuffed with Mozzarella and Basil, the garlic bread with four cheese fonduta and herb butter and the shrimp cocktail. We also ordered the soup special which was a white bean soup. Everything was delicious and filling. Both dipping sauces for the shrimp and garlic bread were superb and we each had favorites. For the main courses I had the veal porterhouse steak, which was excellent, cooked perfectly and accompanied by mushrooms and potatoes. My dinner companions had the gnocchi verde and Parpadelle. Both dishes were delicious and satisfying. We concluded the dinner with two desserts. My daughter is always good for dessert and she got the salted caramel crème brûlée. It was good but she would have preferred if it was warm throughout instead of just on the edges. I explored the sorbetto and gelato and pick a pairing of coconut and blueberries and it was fantastic. Our party of three all concurred. We gave this restaurant a 5 star rating for clean, comfortable atmosphere, excellent food and superior service. You can’t go wrong if you love Italian food like we do.

Trattoria Amalfi is nothing short of a culinary masterpiece, meriting far more than the conventional 5-star rating. The management team goes above and beyond to create a welcoming and luxurious atmosphere, radiating a depth of knowledge about the cuisine and the best ways to elevate your dining experience.

As for the food, it's a symphony for the senses. The executive chef has outdone himself, crafting a menu that combines traditional Italian roots with a contemporary flair. The meatball appetizers set a high standard, enveloped in a blend of herbs and spices that tantalize the palate. This is beautifully complemented by their garlic bread, which is a gastronomic experience in its own right. The texture is crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and comes served with an irresistibly rich cheese sauce and a homemade marinara that bursts with fresh flavors.

In short, Trattoria Amalfi offers an unparalleled dining experience that engages your taste buds and soul. This is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking fine Italian cuisine.

Warm regards,
Dennis Schleicher
YouTuber with 90K+ subscribers and social media influencer.

Walked in expecting an overpriced tourist trap with average food. I was pleasantly surprised at every aspect of my visit. Service was top notch, specifically my bartenders/servers Cody and Kaitlyn! The atmosphere was lively, elegant and family friendly. The food tasted extremely fresh and was absolutely delicious. I ordered the grilled octopus, chicken piccatta, and lemon sorbet. 5/5 would come back! Thank you for a great experience.

This was our second time visiting and both times have exceeded our expectations!
From the women who seated us, to our waiter, the entire staff went above and beyond, they were very knowledgeable on the menu, friendly, and professional! The food was extraordinary, and a great atmosphere to top it off. As locals we will definitely be back, anyone passing through mystic should check this spot out!