Nancy’s Pizza

A new pizza place on a busy road so I stopped in to try them out. Ordered a slice of pizza and garlic knots to go. The garlic knots had fresh garlic on them which several places lack to do. Unfortunately, the knots themselves were fresh and a little chewy. The cheese and the sauce on the pizza had a classic New York flavor. Even down to the grease on the pizza. The dough was chewy like the dough for the knots. I'll give them one more try before passing my final verdict.

First off, I grew up in the north having had the pleasure of experiencing some of the best pizza from Philadelphia to New York. My wife calls me a “Pizza Critic” and that I am way to critical of pizza. I tend to break down a Pizza to its parts and often say things like “well the crust is good but the sauce could be better “ etc.

Now, I am writing this review only after having this pizza for the first time and I must say that this is the best pizza around, and I can’t find fault in anything other than it is a little pricey compared to other local pizza places. We also tried the garlic knots which my wife quoted at “absolutely amazing “.

I highly recommend Nancy’s to anyone looking for the best tasting pizza, and have to say, we now have a new favorite when the pizza mood strikes.

Finally Stuart has a pizza place that is 1.great prices 2. Quality is there! Don’t change anything you guys are doing. Food blogger here and will be back. Went twice in the same week last week because we loved it. Atmosphere was fantastic. Food was fab. Staff were attentive. Great job guys ????

Vacationing in Stuart and so glad we found Nancy's Pizza. Food was excellent! We ordered a large pizza and fettuccine. The fettuccine was amazing and tasted so authentic. Kids said pizza was great. Can't wait to go back next time we're visiting. Owner was so nice and made me feel so welcome! Great experience!

I'm always searching for a better pizza. I definitely found it here! Everything about it was great. The crust, the sauce, the cheese and the toppings. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients and the love they put into it! I will definitely come back here every time I travel to Stuart.