Fogarty's

Food was ok. Nothing special with disappointment. I was disappointed about my food. I ordered Cuban bowl because I love roasted pork and plantain but my plantain is not ripe enough(not sweet and hard) an sky roasted pork was not roasted.

It was our first time to Key West and Duval Street. Fogarty’s got good reviews so we popped in for dinner. Two of us had the IPA and one of us had the island lager. Both were good. We were welcomed and seated promptly at 6:30 PM. They have two bars, which is great. The server was friendly and accommodating, but not pesky! I ordered the fish sandwich and I was blown away by how large that piece of fish was! It had an interesting batter, peppery but delicious. FYI, it’s a large portion. I do recommend recommend it. The fries were perfectly done and crispy. One of us ordered the dolphin sandwich and he said it was good. And the other person in our party ordered the peel and eat shrimp. It was a great experience and we loved the rooster and the small chickens meandering around. I would recommend Fogerty’s for sure.

Located right off Duval Street makes it a perfect people watching perch. Service was fantastic. Surprising for a tourist destination like Key West. Food was great. I had pecan encrusted mahi mahi. Very casual, outdoors, bar like atmosphere. Very noisy. Would come back again.

This was our favorite spot we ate at while visiting Key West. I had the blackened fish tacos, which were the best I've ever had. The food here had great flavor, the service was excellent, and the outdoor seating on Duval Street was fun to take in. I would definitely recommend eating here while visiting Duval Street.

Our favorite for food and drinks in Key West!! Id you’re looking for somewhere to eat on Duval before the sunset, this is your spot! I got the fish sandwich which was fried and fried would not normally be my choice, but it was quite possibly the best fish sandwich I’ve ever eaten! Others in our group got the grilled fish sandwich, a Cobb salad, a burger, and the Tex Mex egg rolls. The burger didn’t come as ordered but our server took full blame because she had misunderstood and quickly had a new burger prepared! Everything we had was delicious, and the frozen Miami Vice, Rum Runner, and Mudslide were yum delish too! Service, food, and atmosphere were all perfect!!!