New York Pasta Garden

We got married in Key West and went to NY Pasta Garden for a small dinner reception. Not only were they wonderful to accommodate our party without a reservation but the waitress Dona was was a complete delight! Her spectacular attitude was both funny and charming. She kept telling all the other customers to congratulate us and even gave us a dessert sample platter at the end of the meal. Thank you so much for the wonderful wedding memories

Our Server Donna was fabulous!!! Top notch service!!! She was welcoming,,pleasant , attentive and lots of laughs! Everything about our experience was exceptional!!!!
See FoodDEEva & Company on Facebook for a full food review.

There are not enough stars! I need thousands of stars
to give an accurate rating. I will recommend New York Pasta Garden above anywhere else in Key West as often as I possibly can. We had our wedding dinner here and the service, food, and accommodations were the best I have ever experienced. Fletcher was the kindest, most welcoming business owner I have ever had the pleasure of working with and went above and beyond to make our dinner flow seamlessly. They offered us “family style” ordering options for our party of 16, including three small children. The atmosphere was stunning and comfortable under the elegant outdoor lighting. Our wedding dinner was some of the best food I have ever had! Not to mention the incredible wine!! We will be back every year .. in fact - it was so good I’ll likely have to get a second job to come down as often as we want for this food alone!!

Thank you Fletcher!! You are incredible and your kindness will forever be etched into our special day!

Pretty good lunch/dinner spot. The garlic knots were very chewy, but flavorful. The hummus was awful- don’t get the hummus. The Greek salad and pasta pomodoro came and they were mediocre. Our waiter was so kind and very attentive. Great location, loved the lights. Great prices.

Good spot in Key West just set back from Duval St. We were served by the owner, and the special menu on Christmas day was great. Big pours of wine too. We will happily come back again soon. There's a large covering out front if you eat outdoors and it happens to be raining. Free parking in the lot.