Fresh Off The Hook

We stopped here for lunch during our stay in the Keys and ordered fried yellowtail sandwiches and a fish basket. The quality of the food exceeded our expectations so much that I felt the need to leave a review for this establishment. We are picky about restaurant cleanliness and food handling and I want to mention how clean the food station appeared to be. We’ll definitely be back. Thank you.

I'm gonna give 5 stars for that sauce and the taste. However, we ordered your fabulous tacos that come with coleslaw. They did not come with coleslaw. We had the shrimp tacos and the yellowtail tacos. BOTH were fantastic, and we WILL be back. The issue I have is that it wasn't complete without the coleslaw. We paid for it and didn't get it. It's expensive to live here. Please pay attention to the orders. Other than that, PEOPLE! Their food is GREAT!

This is a wonderful treasure in Marathon! The food is fresh, always great quality, and it's affordable! Jason and Johnny are friendly, and they always take care of their customers! I love the yellowtail sandwich with tots, and I'm also a fan of their burger! There is some covered seating available if you're looking to eat there, too.

Went to pick up some bait and rain delayed us before heading to the marina. Decided to grab some lunch while we waited and their yellowtail sandwich and homemade chips were outstanding!

It came with two sauces, both were so tasty! Will be back again at some point!