Enrico’s Pizza

We had pepperoni and meatball pizza and you definitely taste the quality ingredients. One of my new favorite pizza places!! Add to that, the staff was friendly, helpful and all around great service. We'll be back and send our friends!

I previously tried their food at Jimmy Johnson's restaurant in Key Largo, but was glad to see they opened up their own location. Great quality pizza. The crust is edible all the way to through the end. I'm from New York City and haven't found pizza this good down in Florida. I also ordered the garlic knits which were also very good. Lots of garlic without the strong garlic taste. I go to the Keys twice a month. Better believe I am stopping by each time.

I’m not going to lie, when I first saw that this was going to be a another pizza place I was skeptical. But I came here within the first couple days of opening and I just went back again last night.

This is NOT just a pizza place, this is an Italian restaurant with Italian appetizers, salads, soups, pasta dishes and deserts. And let’s not forget the amazing pizzas of course!

I lived in Philadelphia for 6 years and on the corner of my city block, there was a place called Franco’s Pizza. It was a family owned business and Franco himself, was almost always in the kitchen making pizzas.

That is how this place is, family owned, great service, good atmosphere and the owners have a vested interest in how the pizzas and food is made. They are either in the kitchen making the pizza or going around to the tables, asking how everyone’s meal is going.

Great customer service, excellent food (the garlic knots and arugula pizza are delicious), great atmosphere and always busy.

If you have considered stopping in, you won’t regret it!

So excited that this place opened up right next to my house. Within walking distance I now have access to the best Pizza I'll ever find on the island. Even better than boardwalk Pizza which occupied that space before Enrico's. Couldn't be happier for the community. now we can finally order pizza again!

Amazing pizza, amazing staff, and amazing food! What more could you ask for? You feel like family the minute you walk in. Can't wait to stop here on the way to the Keys and on the way out. It's that good, I have to go twice!!! Great location and the food is absolutely amazing!! Already planning my next trip back! NEED to try that Lobster Pizza!!