NYPD Pizza at Lake Cay

Buffalo Chicken and Madison Square Garden (add Feta cheese) are the absolute BEST on the menu. Don’t even think about it, just get it. The Buffalo Chicken could probably win a Michelin star rating for the white sauce they put on top of it. Never had anything like it it. And I’ve had all sorts of Pizza from New York. Its much much pricier than any other pizza joint around, but man is it worth the price. They deliver as well. Don’t think twice, THIS is the place to go.

It's tough to claim to be NYC pizza so 3 starts is pretty good. I think the water must effect the dough in NY differently and the cheese is different. Overall, this is a decent pizza.

Great pizza and great flavor! Their eggplant is amazing, fried until it is crispy goodness. The staff is very friendly too. The only thing I would say is that maybe a little more sauce on the pizza would be good. I always ask for a side of sauce and the staff is more than happy to accommodate this request. Some of the best pizza in the area. A must try!

I came to Orlando for vacation with my 6yr old son. After a couple days here we were both just so tired of hotel food and honestly I was tired of spending way too much money. I called NYPD pizza and they delivered in 25 min and directly to my hotel room door. Food was delicious. I give 5 stars for food and 5 stars for service!! Very much appreciated

We arrived from the UK a couple of days ago and looked on google for the best pizza restaurant within 25 miles as we’ve never had pizza in America before. It came up with this restaurant. We were seated promptly and the waitress was very nice. We had calzone and it was amazing. The best pizza I have had in a very long time. Would definitely go back and recommend to others.