Infinity Pizza

We just got a pizza to go and WOW! We are from the Tri-state area and have a hard time finding good New York style pizza here in FL. Well, we found it! My husband always complains about pizza to go, because it gets soggy in the box. He didn’t complain. He inhaled 2 slices without crisping it up in the toaster oven. Happy to find a good pizza place. Place looks like a fun place too. Will have to dine in soon and play a little pinball. Will spread the word because we want to see them succeed. Finally, great pizza and close to home.

Let me start by saying the ordering process online, the ready time and the pizza being ready and hot at pickup was perfect as was the staff being friendly and the restaurant impeccably clean. 4.5 stars for them there. This review is for the pizza though.

I ordered a 14" cheese and added garlic to half in order to get the base flavors of the pie. I ordered it well done and it looked done to perfection and was a very good looking pie overall. Some scorch marks in all the right places, and a perfect covering of cheese.

I instantly grabbed a slice before even leaving the parking lot. The cheese did not break from the pizza as I thought it would. Instead of a stringy gooey pull it looked more grainy like as if it were a cold pizza. My first bit seemed awkward, although the pizza was very crispy it was difficult to separate a bite from the slice. Chewing was likewise and the garlic chunks were still very firm and needed chewing to swallow.

None of this I would consider a BAD pizza, just not what I had hoped for. The main problem and reason for this review was that the pie just didn't have much taste at all. Weather it was the crust or sauce I do not know, but in general just a bland pizza and not worth $16 for a Medium. It's not bad but there are much better options in the area for this kind of money.

Hands down the best pizza and fun spot around. Everyone working here is super kind and can throw down in the kitchen! This is my go to place now. If you’re craving delicious pizza and other fantastic food. Don’t hesitate and stop in here. You will not be disappointed!

Fun place, courteous high-energy staff. I choose the Stromboli instead of pizza and it was great. Loaded with meat and cheese, but still had that crispy crust. When I went, they had a big variety of craft beer in cans and bottles available, which was nice - I got to choose interesting beer without being corralled by just a few boring domestics on tap. I love choice! I didn't try the arcade games on their separate mezzanine, but others were enjoying them. They even had pinball. It reminded me of an old-school pizza parlor, but definitely with a more modern vibe, games, and atmosphere.

Amazing food, amazing customer service. And perfect place for kiddos! They have games in there and now my kids want to go all the time! For someone who has lived in SH my whole life, it brought back west shore pizza vibes but x 10. What an upgrade to the spot! You won’t be let down.