Calogero's Pizzeria

5 stars do it no justice...it deserves 10. Pizza tastes just like New York. I wanted to drive back and get 2 more pies the minute I was done with what I ordered. Their pizza is authentic, ingredients are imported from Italy. You can tell right away with the sauce. Pricing is fantastic and the portions are the perfect size. Thank You, Calogero's Pizzeria. You took the time to introduce us first timers and it's great you're in Lake Alfred to provide the best of New York, right here in Florida.

Ohhh i can't begin to tell you how good the pizza is here! Its everything the reviews said and more. We have looked for a good pizza place since we moved here 12 years ago and finally found it! People said the pizzas were small but they are medium to large size. It will be nice to not have to go to Orlando for a good authentic pizza

The last time I ate a delicious pizza like this was in Rome, Italy! We order the Macellaio, Pepperoni, and Queens. My husband loves pizza 🍕 and for his birthday we decide to pickup the order. It's really hard to get a "It's really good" from him! And he loved it. Also, next time we will eat there, the place seems lovely!

I drove one hour each way to get this pizza and it was worth every second of it. I would include a picture but I ate my pie too fast. If you are in the area or one hour away I strongly recommend the pizza here. I'll be making the pilgrimage to come back here once a month from now on. The owner is great and very friendly, come here and enjoy some good pizza!

Best pizza we’ve had in a while. All of the ingredients are so fresh and you can tell the difference. The pizzas have just the right amount of smoky flavor from the fire. The tomato sauce to cheese ratio is perfect. No complaints at all on taste.

The owner is the best part of this place. He has came and talked with my husband and I each time we’ve been. Super down to earth staff.

My only recommendations for this restaurant is access to bathrooms and trash cans. I may have just missed them though!