Miei Amici Pizzeria

Being born and raised in the Northeast, one thing I know is good pizza and let me tell you- this pizza is the real deal. St. John’s hit the jackpot with Miei Amici. The plain pie is a nice thin crust with no flop and a nice sweet sauce and that nice stringy cheese. The butcher pie was phenomenal and the owner Vincenzo made us a calzone which is up there with the best I’ve ever had. Do not miss out on trying this place!

Ordered takeout for the first time on a very busy Friday night. We were not prepared for the size of the calzones. To say they are large is an understatement. You can definitely feed at least 3 people on 1. They were delicious. The garlic knots were also delicious and very garlicky.

One bite…everyone knows the rules.

Score: 8.4

Best pizza 🍕 in Saint Johns 🌴

Heard really good things about this pizza spot and it did not disappoint. You can buy a whole pie or you can take advantage of pizza-by-the slice. The undercarriage had that lovely coal taste and the sauce was delicate & sweet. I was honestly shocked by just how good that first bite of a pepperoni slice was!

If you know the significance of an “8” on the OneBite rating system, you’d head down to this spot before it’s no longer a local best kept secret.

Truly a neighbood Pizzeria! We enjoyed meeting neighbors and chatting while we waited for our food.

For our pizza choice we ordered the Butcher Shop. This pizza was loaded with all the meats! At first I was questioning the price, but this pie has fed my husband and 3+ meals.

We also ordered the chicken Parma hero. It took us two sittings to finish half the hero (each of us enjoying a slice of pizza at each sitting also). The flavor was delicious! It reminded me of the sandwiches I use to enjoy in NY.

We will definitely be back. So close, so friendly, so yummy!!

Great food and service!! You can tell the team is working hard. Everyone was friendly and welcoming. We took home a butcher shop. Pizza was hot, crust nice and thin, sauce is delicious, well balanced and not too sweet. Will look forward to trying more of the menu.