Two Fat Guys Italian Gourmet Deli

This adorable family run Italian deli is incredible!!! I stopped In For fresh cannolis and they were handmade right away ! The lentil soup is by far the best ever and vegan! The 3 bean salad with fresh beans, tomatoes, chick peas and cucumbers rocked and the marinated shrooms were also to die for for ! Wow ! Thank you guys for putting your heart into all this delicious food. Can’t wait to come back xo my son loves their Italian ice from NY :)

Loved the aroma of store and the food we bought. The fresh mozz, parsley and cheese sausage ring was quite tasty and the rice ball. My daughter had the Bensonhurst on semolina and raved about the bread. I had a bite or two and loved the sandwich.

The accents were great, raised on Staten Island I always feel home when I hear it.

We'll be back.

I dont know what's better, the service or the food?!?!? I came in for tuna on rye but they were out so I asked if I could have a #24 but with eggplant instead since I don't eat chicken. They didn't hesitate to say no problem and it was AMAZING. The line moved super fast and everyone was extremely friendly and you can tell the food is made with LOVE. I absolutely recommend two fat guys!

First visit today. They made me a custom sandwich to my specifications and I couldn't be happier. Met the staff along with Carmine the manager and all are the real deal deli people making sure you get what you want. Store has quality products and I think you can't go wrong. Give it a try you will not regret your visit.