Bennie's Red Barn

Yes Bennie’s is BACK! Tonight the service (Jamie) was incredible.
Folks there are some bad reviews out there with time issues.
Well let me educate you on how top quality food is prepared...the guys in the kitchen (Greg & company) prepare each meal to order. You can bet it is worth the wait...The prime steaks are hand cut and cooked over a live oak fired grill. Get ready there is no where this can be replicated. Simple flavors done right! Done miss this when on SSI. Plus this is the landmark restaurant on SSI.

I went to dinner here this evening; from the minute I entered the front door of Bennie’s the staff made me feel like family. There was an event going on so I was escorted to another dining area (situated behind the bar). Amy, my waitress; was wonderful. She made it a point to check on me (and chat) even when I had everything I needed. Management also approached me to make sure that I was enjoying my meal. I couldn’t have asked for better service.

The food was very good; I had the Cowboy (bone in) Ribeye.

I will definitely be back with my family.

We always have a great time while there. Servers are excellent. On multiple visits our steaks were off even when we come before the dinner rush on slow days. Just minor consistency issues in the kitchen. Otherwise, it's a staple on the island that should be around forever. When it's good, it's great.

Food and service was beyond amazing!! Best restaurant on the island! Wow factor above perfect! Wish I could post the video of the gentleman singing. Over the top impressed with food, service and atmosphere. Well worth it. Our waiter was also on point from the menu to the service. Thank you for our wonderful experience. I will definitely be back.