Peytons Pie Company - Gainesville

I had the greasy New Yorker, and it was incredible 🔥 . Great crust cooked well with fresh simple sauce, perfect amount of fresh mozz and the plastic on top inside the box kept it double insulated and warm for quite awhile…Thanks Archie! Incredible pie! Will definitely be back again….

The pizza at Peyton’s is so delicious! This visit we tried the My Honey is Hotter Than Yours and The Super Billy with a little side of the balsamic ranch. Yall, it about made my tongue slap my brains out it was so good! The wood fired stone oven gave it a kiss of smoke that was perfect…You have to try this place if you haven’t yet! Our only regret is we didn’t come here sooner. We agree that we found our new favorite pizza spot around! Our only regret is not trying it sooner! See you same time next week! #LegalizeMarinara

Peyton's Pie Company in Gainesville offers a delightful experience. The Seahorse Pizza, boasting a flavorful combination of pepperoni, red onion, peppadew peppers, and fresh mozzarella, is an absolute standout. The delicious crust adds an extra layer of perfection to the pizza. Moreover, the staff's friendly demeanor contributes to the welcoming atmosphere. A must-visit for exceptional pizza right on the square in Gainesville!

In the gainesville area this is one of my favorite pizza pie places. We have tried most of the pies they offer and all have been awesome. :) Has a very good relaxed atmosphere. The pies themselves have nice thin crispy crust and chewy pizza bone. The fresh toppings rock. The Greasy New Yorker is one of my favorites along with the SFC.