Erika's Place

I’ve frequented the Cicero location for many years, and it’s always been amazing. The Noblesville location is no different. Amazing food, great prices and service with a smile. Don’t pass this up, it’s worth it every time!

Everything that makes a local restaurant great, Erika's has it nailed. I just got home from at least the tenth time I've been there since it opened. The food has always been fresh, hot and delicious. The portions are generous and very reasonably priced: A one-pound baked potato loaded with fork tender pot roast and topped with melted cheese, with gravy on the side for around $10! The service has always been first rate. Before a drink is empty, somebody always comes by to offer a refill. Whenever friends and family visit from California, Erika's is the first place we eat. It's locally-owned and a wonderful addition to our town.

Although the staff here was very friendly, I was shocked to see that the entire kitchen staff and the servers are no longer wearing masks. I understand that while this doesn’t bother a lot of people, my friends and I were really put off. Plus, it’s not the largest restaurant, so social distancing isn’t possible. My friends said their food was amazing, but had I known they were no longer wearing masks, I would’ve thought twice about joining them. Just a heads up to anyone else who may have the same concerns.

Legitimately had some of the best French toast I have ever tasted. I had to do a double take at my plate to confirm it was just French toast I had ate. The rest of the breakfast was average but the French toast is worthy of 5 stars on its own.

Enjoyed the atmosphere and the food. Great menu with lots of variety and choices. Settled on the tenderloin. Wife had beef Manhattan. Plan to return soon to try other items