Prodigy Burger Bar

Food was very good...I was in search of a great burger and Prodigy provided! Ordered the three sliders and it's a perfect way to try three great burgers. We will be back to try the milkshakes with our next meal!

A friend and I came here on a Saturday night, excited to see what all the hype was about.  We got the fried green tomatoes appetizer, which was around $8 and was delicious. Spicy ranch paired great with them.

For my main entree, I got the fried egg & bacon burger.  Ordered it medium, with onion rings.  Burger came out well done- but I was starving, so I didn't say anything about it to our waitress. The burger was  OK. It's definitely not worth the $18 I spent on it. I could go to Kumas Corner in Fountain Square and get a much better burger for less than $18. The onion rings were OK, batter was good, but the onion was cut a little thicker than my liking.

We sat bar top, and the service was good.  Waitress was nice. Burger seemed to take a while to come out, but they were very busy, so I won't fault them for that.

Overall, I would go again to try the peanut butter smash burger, which would hopefully be worth the $14 price tag.

First visit. Most tables were full so we opted for bar seating. Several empty tables and no one sitting at the bar. We had a Mac & cheese burger with loaded fries and a Hoosier Daddy with Mac & cheese. One of the 2 bartenders came over quickly to take our drink order and delivered them quickly and said she give us a couple of minutes to peruse the menu. We were seated in the farthest corner seat, so I do give some latitude for that but 13 minutes passed before she came back. We had put down our menus and were looking in their direction trying to catch their eye. After we gave our orders, they came out hot and fresh 24 minutes later. The sandwiches come standard with fries and you pay a little extra for “loaded”. We decided to get loaded fries instead of an appetizer. Loaded fries to us means bacon and cheese, probably with a side of sour cream or ranch. Loaded fries here are what we know as chili cheese fries. We didn’t love them. The burger, tenderloin and Mac & cheese were delicious. My only complaint would be the lack of attention by the bartenders. But again we were seated at a crowbar table.