Lombardi's New York Pizza and Wings

Great pizza. Had slices ready to go like every great NY pizzeria should! Also tried the rice ball which was delish! Friendly staff.

If you’re in Southern Indiana and craving a foldable slice of Brooklyn pie, this one is worth checking out. It is pretty close to what I call NY style pizza, which I find subjective anyway (even if I am not a New Yorker). I’ve eaten many slices of pie at multiple NY pizzerias/delis all over the five Burroughs of NY, and they are all different, but at least similar in design, and this one meets the basic criteria for NY style pie (to me, an outsider). A nice thin crust with a little “pull” to it, and a bit thicker around the edges (I call it the pie grip) . Sauce was good (not great, but pretty good). Quality toppings, not too much or too little, just the right amount. In short, it is a well balanced pizza and far beyond anything you’ll get at ANY chain pizzeria. The location is off the beaten path (in a strip mall of sorts), so unless you live in the neighborhood, you could easily miss it. Not much to say about the decor and ambience of the place, but the same can be said for so many other restaurants with Great food. In fact, most NY style pizzerias and delis I have been to are much the same; the focus is on the food, not the atmosphere. If you’ve got good pie though, who cares about what color the walls are or whether the table you’re eating at cost more than your car. I should point out that I ordered a whole pie, not just a slice, which makes a difference IMO. I will just have a slice for lunch next time I am in the area though to see if there is much difference in the par cooked slices compared to a whole pie.

The arancini is wonderful! Pizza is fantastic too! Great food and great music playing. Amazing prices!! Definitely will return!

Fantastic pizza! Rivals any NY style pizza I had. The cheese is very flavorful, topping seem very fresh. The owner is very nice and is happy to answer any questions. We got a half margarita and half pepperoni, mushroom, and jalapeño. We will definitely be back!

Just came back from New York had a lot of pizza so after we have been back I found Lombardi's New York pizza. I will have to agree it taste just like New York pizza the sauce was great cheese and pizza dough we're cooked to perfection had a great time. It has a cozy environment. I notice a lot of people coming in for take out. It's worth the drive.