Maple Street Pizza Company

This place was a delight for the palate!! My husband and I shared the cheesy bread and buffalo chicken calzone. I had the Italian salad and he had the Caesar. Everything was full of flavor and did not disappoint. The soda was the perfect mix of syrup and carbonation....something I always long for when ordering a soda in a restaurant. We will be back!!

We started with sharing a Caesar salad, which they graciously offer to split on two plates. The dressing was tangy and had a bit of spicy black pepper. The home-made croutons were little jewels in this salad as they had just the right seasonings and added the needed crunch factor! The Chicken Florentine pizza was delicious having a creamy white sauce that was accented with roasted garlic cloves, artichoke hearts, chicken chunks, red onion slices, and fresh spinach leaves all atop a superb crust!! The drink that caught my eye was the Islamorada, that brought the tropical rums and juices together with just enough kick and sweetness to satiate my need for a sweet splurge-definitely liquid sunshine for me! Next time, I'll try to save room for dessert.
The only problem I can see is the place is small, and if this great pizza place is shared by all who love the flavors, they'll need a bigger space in the near future.

Had a wonderful first experience! They were busy but quickly accommodated our party of 6. Cheesy bread was amazing, and the marinara has a nice little bite to it. I had the Primo Calzone and Italian salad; hubby and son shared the Carnivore pizza. We waited a bit for the s'more dessert pizza, but it was worth it. Everything was delicious, hot, and super fresh!!

Met a friend for a long overdue dinner to catch up. She had the White Sangria and it looked delicious. We split the Baked Ricotta appetizer, a Caesar Salad, and How I Met Your Mother pizza. Every was FANTASTIC. The meatballs on the pizza we ah-mazing. The crust was the perfect blend of crunch and chewy, not too thick and not too thin. We’ll definitely be back!

We took our girls 6 and 2 with us to eat dinner here on Friday night. The restaurant was full and they said it would be a 20 min wait...but I think they were over estimating to be safe and it was closer to 10. Once we were sat it went pretty smooth. There were no kids meals listed but they did have kid size pizzas with 1 topping. Both my girls got cheese of course! Hubby and I ordered the Carnivore. All pizza was delicious. Crust was cooked perfectly. 1 pizza was enough for me and my husband to each have 4 pieces. Plenty to fill us up. Wait staff was so nice! My daughter ordered an Italian soda for the first time and didn't enjoy the cream. We asked for a Dr Pepper instead but said we would keep the Italian one for others at the table to drink. He came back with the Dr Pepper but also brought my daughter a new cherry soda with no cream...and she was in love. The restaurant is a little small but had a very nice cozy fill. By the end of the meal my daughter was telling me she was ready to move in.