Bennie's Pizza

Edit: I've got to lower my score after trying their margherita. There was so much garlic on this pizza that I couldn't taste anything else. I couldn't finish a single slice. It also had absolutely no crisp fresh out of the oven. Nothing like the first pie I got from them.

Original review: One of the best NY style pizzerias in MD.

The pizza and wings are great! We ordered take out and really enjoyed the food.

I’d say it’s the best pizza in the Columbia area! While I didn’t eat inside, I went inside to pick up the food, and the bar and ambiance looked fun and vibrant!

Cool vibe in what used to be the sit down restaurant side of Chicken & Whiskey. The pizza lived up to the hype. Perfectly cooked thin crust, slightly spicy sauce, really flavorful cheese, and cup pepperoni, which is always best. The chicken Parmesan sub was on great bread with super crispy, yet moist chicken, fresh mozzarella and basil. Really really good. The fries were perfectly cooked thin fries with the right amount of salt as well. Service was friendly and fast. Drinks were great. Highly highly recommend. May have instantly become Howard County's best pizza.

I left this place happy. Went on opening night and the owner was super nice and the atmosphere was cool. The pizza though? Outstanding. Perfect crust, cheese and sauce. The sauce had flavor. The cheese was stringy and just like a New York slice. There’s only one size pizza and I love that they don’t do pineapples on pizza. Can’t wait to come back.