Edgartown Meat & Fish Market

Nice selection of meat and fish. The butcher counter staff is curt and rushed despite the fact that there are so few customers and you are spending top dollar.

I'm here to speak of its bagels...some of the best homemade fresh bagels ever! I love the everything bagel -- 5 days later, it is a little dry but soft - toast it up and its like fresh again. They don't go rock stale like commercial junk. I don't get gaseous from these gluten bagels prob bcs they ferment them properly instead of using crazy preservatives to speed things up. Great paired with some local cheese and honey

Little pricey but great food, coffee and staff :)

This is your one stop shop on island! As someone that lives in Edgartown year round, I appreciate having a market like them open through the winter. Reasons why I love it: they have well stocked shelves of essentials but also fun pantry items - if you want to make any kind of ethnic food, they have sauces and spices to go with your meal. Their meat and seafood cases are always packed with deliciousness. Try their steak tips on the grill, you will fall in love! They also sell side dishes that are great for when you need to put together a quick dinner. Need ice cream? They've got it. Fresh mushrooms and vegetables? They have them! Freshly made sushi rolls? YES! Frozen fried onion rings? Yup, they have them! Plus wine and beer, a Starbucks outpost for everyone the needs their SB hit from time to time, plus they carry so many local products like MV Sea Salt and Val Cakes desserts and Not Your Sugar Mamas coffee. Overall, just an awesome market and the owners are local to the island and the nicest people ever, the staff is so friendly and always helpful!