Original Buscemi's

I just placed a order never mind I have been customer for 20 years Seems I was bothering the person that pick up the phone. This is the last time I order from them.

Ordered from here tonight for the first time, the pizza was hot and delicious, fast, free delivery too. We will definitely be ordering from here again, truly amazing.

I've been to the place twice. First time was okay, yet not special. Second time was not really good (I'd give 2 stars). Phone ordering process sucked. Despite the menu stating Calzones/Pizza Rolls, the order person insisted it was called Pizza Pocket (which is a horrible name for this product). Pizza pocket brings up disgusting image of frozen bricks that you get at a grocery store and thaw in a microwave to a tasteless chewy rubber brick. The pizza pocket I got from Monroe Buscemis was pretty close to that. While not exactly rubbery, it was moderately chewy and fairly tasteless. They don't have many options and refused making an Italian Calzone and waited for me to order exactly what's on the menu, or bust. Seeing how the place isn't busy, I'd prefer a bit more openness to pleasing the customer, and a bit more explaining my options (we can't make this but can do this instead, etc.) instead of meeting me with a wall of silence when I order something like an Italian Calzone. If I was Chef Ramsey I'd f* scream.

I'd go to Buscemi's on Monroe street or another pizza place. They have made Italian Calzones for me in the past, and whatever they prefer to call it, tasted better, and the service seemed more friendly.