Joe's New York Pizza

We got the Frat Boy Greek pizza, best pizza I've had in a long time, loved the crust, loved the sauce, loved how the base crust gets a little soggy in the center of the pie, thank you, you are now our favorite pizza joint!!

The pizza sort of reminds me of a Jersey/NY slice. The taste is almost there. But let's face it local pizza will never taste the same in another state. The fries are on piont ...crispy but not overcooked. There is also garlic knots. Which are covered in buttery garlicky tastiness. The variety of pizza toppings is insane. Like the meat pizza stuffed with meatballs, sausage, and bacon. Or the buffalo chicken with actual real moist chicken pieces. They also have salads. The prices have gone up a bit but I think it's worth it. Because you're getting better quality food. It's hard to find a pizza spot that puts as much effort into pizzas as a restaurant does it's main courses. Update...prices are a little bit more than your corner pizza shop. So be prepared to pay extra for better ingredients.

Good pizza, it feels like about the closest thing I can get to NY pizza on the seacoast, where Greek pizza (while good) is the standard fare. I like dropping in at lunch, having a few slices and being on my way in under 15 minutes if need be. I, too, have eaten pizza in NY when I lived there, but unlike most of these reviewers, I don't think paying rent in Manhattan makes me an expert on what makes a good pizza. I've eaten plenty of 'only OK' pizza in NYC as well. There's nothing magical that makes the pizza there good; just good ingredients and a good recipe. This reminds me of NY Pizza.

That said, as much as I don't want to say this, the per slice amount there is getting a bit out of control. I think it was 4.25 for a slice of cheese when I went last week, and over 5 bucks for a slice with a few toppings.

It's hard to justify 15+ bucks on two slices of pizza, a garlic knot and a coke. It's where I like to eat out at lunch from work best, but that's getting to be a tough pill to swallow. I guess ordering a whole pizza is cheaper? But I don't want, nor need, a whole pizza. So sadly I think I'll have to cut back on Joe's because of the cost.

Real good pizza and friendly staff though. I've never met the rude staff that people have mentioned; everyone is always really friendly, though I always go in during the lunch shift, so maybe nights the people are rude? I don't know.

I’m ONLY giving a 4 because they were short staffed when I visited them last night. In actuality they deserve a 4.5 for great tasting pizza and salad. I was impressed with the level of customer service given by this one young man, working ALONE and was LITTERALLY running and sliding all over the work area trying to keep up with the demand of the orders he had. I wish I’d asked him for his name, but I felt so bad that I didn’t want to waste 1 second of his time! He was so polite, apologetic and (seemingly) in control of the situation while his co-worker ran deliveries and made salads.
In spite of doing the job of several people (with a smile and a nice word) the food was very good!
I will try them again, due to the quality of the food and customer service, even under duress! I have hopes of a full staff next time, which may make for an even better experience.
Thank you nameless pizza man who was working on the eve of 5/8/19 around 7:00pm, I hope the owner realizes what a valuable employee he has and rewards you as such!
Marlene

Pizza by the slice at its best! These guys are excellent service quick to move and get your order done. Never had an issue with the food or service. Still has that nostalgic pizza house feel with a couple arcade games in the front windows.