Johnny's Pies

Stopped in again, always consistent always great!! Wow wow wow! We had the margarita pizza which has the olive oil on it that is so delicious. We also had the pepperoni which had honey and hot peppers for great extra taste! The crust is thin and crispy and the mild char around the edges is awesome. For extra deliciousness, get the garlic shrimp appetizer and hold on to the extra garlic sauce to dip your crust in! Thanks to Emily our waitress for not only suggesting that but for upselling us on everything including the unique yummy desserts. Service was awesome. Place is not huge and has limited tables so as the word gets out it will surely be harder to get in. Cool open pizza making area is the center of the place, so it is fun to watch them make all the delicious pies.

Absolutely amazing pizza. A total hidden gem buried in south jersey.
Being a boy from Brooklyn who grew up in pizzerias , i know pizza.
This is as legit as it gets.
Charred Crust, soft center, not too sweet, fresh mutz. Legit !!

I dined in with family on a Friday evening and we got seated almost immediately! Even though take out was over an hour, we received our food in less than 20 minutes. The server was attentive and the owner was so friendly. Very genuine family owned business. We will be back!

This is my second time coming here and I had an even better experience. Awesome pizza, great staff, amazing service. This place is a hidden gem. The pies are well done, perfectly, and only come in one size. They’re open Wednesday thru Saturday, from 4:00 to I think 8:00, make sure you find out hours before going. I got the pepperoni with peppers and a pepperoni with no peppers, both were awesome!

How on God's green earth has this place only a 4 star? This is some of the best pizza in NJ, fresh ingredients, nice staff to look at and a char on the crust that was perfectly cooked. This isn't your neighborhood pizza pasta place this is pizza for those of us who enjoy better than those places