Teglia Pizza Bar

Consistently excellent pizza. It's a different style here, rectangular and baked in a pan, but don't call it Sicilian!

No question, the best pizza in Montclair. It’s not your normal round pie like Panzano’s, it’s stunning house-made dough with gorgeous toppings that’re mostly housemade also. My wife and I are addicted.

Teglia has some of the best pizza I have found around Montclair and beyond. A perfect blend of crispy outer but chewy inner crust, these giant pies are a must-try! The pepperoni they use is also excellent quality compared to other pizza places, which makes the taste and texture of their pepperoni pizza even better. I have only ever ordered delivery, so cannot comment on the inside/sit-in of the restaurant.

delicious! my second time having the classic roni pie & the pepperoni is always crisp and cooked perfectly. tried the farmers pie for the first time and it is to die for. the crust is phenomenal as well.

Our first experience at Teglia was great! The unique pizza crust was delicious and had just the right amount of toppings. It made us reminisce of our italian grandmother's pizza and that's a good thing! Our only regret is that we didn't order more pizzas. We look forward to going back soon.