Tony Boloney's Hoboken

Pizza is decent when it is hot. It was not hot. Asking the staff to warm up the pizza should not be met with eye rolling and obnoxiousness. Take your money to Benny Tudino's just down the road. They're good folk. $4 for a regular slice is ridiculous. So is only having Fiji water. It's precisely as wet as all other water. Hipster trash.

Edit: the owner has informed me that the poor service is not standard. In addition, he's not hipster trash. I guess the place is fine. Bring your own water. Fiji can go gargle peanuts.

I want to give this place five stars because the pizza was So. Freaking. Delicious. Incredibly inventive toppings, I don't want to spoil it for you by telling you some of the meats and vegetables you'll never find in any other pizzeria. It was night, and some of the slices looked a little tired. So I respectfully asked my server to please put mine in the oven for an extra long time, to make sure the cheese melted and it got hot all the way through. It would have been even tastier. But like many other people commenting here, they just didn't leave it in the oven long enough. I wouldn't have minded waiting. I shall return, but I'll be more vigilant next time. My wife thought it was too salty. I disagree.

The pizza was not warmed up well so it put a damper on our experience. I feel like it would have really good if they had a fresh pizza on site or heated until the pizza was nice and not. The soda on the other hand was great. Not show if it was local or homemade or specialty but it was not the regular coke or Pepsi and it was really good.

We thought this pizza was great. Small space, counter service. Great walkable neighborhood. Toppings were plenty & flavorful. Crust was perfect. Menu is extensive & creative. 5 people, 2 pizzas, a slice, appetizer and couple drinks was $60. Well worth it.

EDIT: Called ahead of the super bowl to make sure I wouldn’t have an issue with my order being delivered on super bowl Sunday and my order was still an hour late, and my sandwich was incorrect. HOWEVER I called the store and the manager ordered me a new sandwich and PERSONALLY hand delivered it to me in 15 minutes flat and even gave me a call after to triple check if anything further could have been done. Compared to their service in the past , you can tell Tony’s is fully committed to 100% service excellence this time around so THANK YOU TONY’S