Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe

Amazing fresh seafood cooked to perfection. Would have easily been 5 stars except the service was perhaps a little spotty on a busy Saturday night. We will be back many times no doubt.

I love this place. Specially make a biweekly trip to eat their New England Clam Chowder. Wow!

Unassuming storefront disguises the comfortable and nicely appointed dining area just a sharp turn to the right from the fresh seafood case. Arctic Char lunch special was exceptional! Will be back.

This restaurant is better than a hidden gem. Food was tasty and fresh. The Manhattan Clam chowder was seasoned perfectly. Service was great also. I will definitely return. Portions were appropriate for the price.

Two part review. The seafood side - Always fresh! I've never purchased anything here that was old or bad. The guys are super knowledge which I find to be an added bonus when you aren't sure about something or want to know what's 'fresh'. The restaurant side - is really hit or miss. We've ate here a couple of times. Once for dinner when they were literally out of almost everything on the menu (including soup). We also had to wait for over an hour to sit and then be told this (not sure why they didn't tell people who were waiting but there you go). We tried it a second time (this time for lunch) and it was actually really good. A little pricey for the portion side but still good. Not sure I would go here again to eat but definitely a great place to pick up seafood to cook yourself!