Coniglio's Old Fashioned

I drove from NYC all the way over there because the pizza is amazing!!!

I was really excited to try their pizzas! The place looks fantastic! The ambiance is amazing! The location is awesome! I loved their menu options!
We tried 3 different pizzas. Brooklyn Round was our favorite, the whole family really enjoyed it. I personally liked Meatball Pizza but everyone said it was just okay. And our least favorite was Vodka Pizza, it didn’t have enough sauce or flavor. Their dough is fantastic though, I can tell they use really good ingredients.
I’ll definitely come back to try more pizzas.

Still limited menu as they are just opening up. We got the grandma pie -- good flavor. Thick crust. Looking forward to going back to try the thin crust and the sandwiches which sound amazing!

Me and my friends have been waiting months for this place to open and it did not disappoint in any way. This pizza is lightyears ahead in quality compared to anything in the area. Seriously fantastic pizza (we had the grandma pie with half pepperoni). Staff was great, inside is clean and decorated nicely. The owner was friendly. We ended up hanging out for awhile and had some of their in house bread and a sandwich to share. Also both insanely good and I will be buying bread here now. I don’t often write reviews, but I am really hoping this place sticks around and does well. This is the pizza Morristown has been waiting for.

Been waiting for months for this place to open, I will say it was worth the wait! We came on their 2nd day open and initially ordered a grandma pie. After being told they were out of sauce we were offered a Vodka Sicilian. The pie came out fresh and hot a few minutes later. The sauce was fresh and flavorful, and the dough was equally delicious.

They offer subs as well and have a coffee bar. We can't wait to try it all!

Morristown needed a place like this! Glad they are finally here.