The pizza was great but I find the hours are horribly inconsistent. You really get that home made pie feel and because its BYOB and that is a true benefit. Sometimes the owner will actually share from his personal liquor cabinet as well.
As soon as the heavenly pizza was delicately placed on my taste buds, I rethought my life and what everything in this world meant. Never have I ever experienced such blessed pizza in my many years on this earth. Stillmano’s pizza should definitely get a Michelin star for its outstanding service and quality. I eat here every Monday, Wednesday, Friday, and on most sundays.
Great pies and selection. We took down the Grandma w/ homemade vodka sauce, famous bar pie, Meat lovers special, buffalo chicken pie, and all amazing. Full bar. TVs and sports games on. Wisconsin cheese always fresh. Met the owner and his wife- great local people and staff.
Stillmanos Pizza is life changing. The crust is crispy and soft and perfect like a spring morning. The sauce is outstanding there are very few hairs in it. the owner will literally walk the pizza to your house if you ask. (Please note - the pizza is a mild laxative and very strong sedative - especially pepperoni - definitely do not plan a night out or operate machines )
You've heard of speakeasy lounges...this is the hidden spot for pizza! Once you find this secret location, you will have some of the best, freshly made pizza you will ever taste! Highly recommend and let me know if you want to place an order...I know a guy that knows a guy that can get you in!