Gialy's

Delicious gluten free pasta dinner. The. Marinara sauce was awesome. Historic atmosphere and friendly service.

Hit or miss. Either it was excellent or just so/so. Ive been twice, not sure if Ill be back since last time wasnt very good. 1st time was excellent but a month later..no. its been over a year since ive been there now.

Visiting town in upstate NY on way to Niagara Falls. At a loss for a good place to eat. Gialy’s was on a long list of restaurants recommended by our hotel, so we chose that one, as we were in the mood for Italian food. I’m always hesitant to go Italian, especially when in a new area, as I’m from a big Italian family, with lots of chefs, and also in the restaurant business. I HIGHLY recommend it! The food was fantastic! Service was great, even tho we didn’t have reservations, but I would suggest them, in case it can be a busy night, as tonite was. Portions were tremendous. We shared a Burrata appetizer (glad we shared, as dinner portion was huge), followed by Lobster Ravioli and Chicken Parmesan/ Spaghetti, both served with a nice fresh salad and bread.

Fantastic venue! Brought my girlfriend and her parents here to give them a taste of what Jamestown has to offer and we were not disappointed. The establishment was clean, tasteful, and classy. You don't need reservations, but it is recommended. They had a wonderful drink selection, great starters, fantastic entrees, and delectable deserts. The soups were hot and tasty, salads were fresh and crisp, and bread was warm. We had ordered pasta dishes and a steak dish for our main entrees and they all came out hot, how we ordered, and were freshly made. Our waitress was personable and professional at all times which really added to the experience. The dining room was well lit and well laid out with plenty of different seating arrangements and enough space between other tables so you could carry on a conversation the entire night. I work at the Chautauqua Harbor Hotel and I will definitely be recommending this restaurant to every guest that stays with us!