Otto's Restaurant

Service was great. Prices very reasonable.
Italian food was especially good and portions were very generous. Will be going back again.

I walked in with a sub on my mind, but ended up eating two slices of pepperoni pizza that were quite enjoyable. If you love pizza that is cheesy and greasy, then you will not be disappointed here. I had sauce and oil on my hands after wolfing down my two slices, which were piping hot. If you prefer to eat pizza with your hands you will need napkins and for some that makes eating it even more enjoyable!

Decent not great. If home cooked means tomato paste instead of flavorful pasta sauce then Otto's will taste home cooked to you. Not terrible and large portions for the price salvage this restaurant, but there are much better Italian offerings.

I really like Otto's, always have. The bar, the dining room, staff etc. Like their spaghetti sauce a lot! Portions are very generous, plenty of options on the menu as well. The reason they don't earn a 5 star rating is because I asked for my wings crispy. I say "when the cook feels they are crispy, leave them in for another minute or 2, then they are ready." Waitress acknowledges but they are not crispy when served. A bit rubbery in fact. Good size wings too. More often than not, many places can't get this right. I expect it in Florida, but I'm in Buffalo man! Bringing home to grill them up tomorrow!
My eppie roll was excellent! As were the other guests dinners.