Nicky's Pizza

Nicky's is a pretty average pizzeria. The pizza isn't bad, but this is not a destination location. The garlic knots are excellent. The service is fast and the staff is pleasant.
Nicky's is just an ordinary, neighborhood pizza joint, so if you're hungry you can't go wrong.

Been coming here for the last 10 years and Jimmy and his team punch out great food all the time, my boys will not eat any other pizza but here.

There pizza good , but pricey

Delicious pizza and freshly prepared Italian dishes upon request at a local neighborhood clean and well managed pizzeria and more. You will not be disappointed with a visit to Nicky for a satisfying meal.

I live in suffolk county and was in the area to pick up car parts so I passed by this place and wanted to give it a try, $20 for a whole pie and 2 drinks. The staff were very nice and the pizza I ordered was very good! If I'm in the area again this is definitely my first place to go.