Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels

The best bagels in brooklyn hands down. These are not these huge NYC bagels that will ruin your day. They're a tad smaller... but it's a good thing. Quite tasty.

The only downside? Check your order. If I ask for whole wheat everything bagel, 9 times out of 10 I either get whole wheat or everything... If it happens once I figure it's a flop but almost every single time I go there I have to check the order and fix it before I leave....I'm not sure how/why it's happening... but it's also not keeping me from my beloved bagels.

The fish is excellent & the bagels taste good. The restaurant needs to have some paper menus available, & it'd be great if they're able to add espresso options or outdoor seating at some point.

Tried the whole wheat and sesame bagels. The crust was great and the sourdough starter came through. These are smaller bagels that are dense and chewy — not the typical NY bagel nowadays.

The sesame bagel had way, way too much salt on it making it difficult to eat. They need to advertise it as a sesame-salt bagel. I would not have made the purchase had I known that it was topped with salt.

Great bagels. Also have lard bread. The pretzel bagel us awesome with cream cheese!! 👍

Good bagel s clean