Hometown Pizzeria Canastota

The $5 lunch special is AWESOME! This place might not serve the best classic NY style pizza, but the slices are huge and the people are always super friendly.

Not a very good quality pizza. Definitely seems like a premade dough, not fresh. Not something you would expect from a local pizzeria. I'd compare it to a chain but even the chains have fresh dough these days. They really need to sell the conveyor oven, destroys what pizza should be, and get a traditional pizza oven. Staff were very friendly so it does bother me I'm being so blunt but it has to be said. And put some effort into the atmosphere. Even a cool atmosphere can bring in business when the food doesn't. Just really needs some work. Starting with the dough and the oven.

Consistently good food. Love their dough...they will happily create your favorite pizza. Orders always correct and ready on time. Our new 'go to'

The slices of pizza are enormous and everything was fresh. Two slices for $5 is well worth it. I gave them four stars because the specialty pizza crust did not seem cooked all the way. Besides that it was delicious.