Supreme’s Pizzeria & Ristorante

After prepaying, waited over 2 hours and pizza never came. Nobody answered the phone. I get that's it's busy but this is crazy that they stopped answering the phone. Update: came after 2.5 hours. I was on hold for 13 mins and if I didn't call doubt it would have come. They did refund our money so that was good. I guess just bad night. Pie was not hot-hot because I'd guess it was 90 mins late.

A ton of places have been here in the many years I've been on the island. This is possibly the best thing that's been in this spot that I can remember. And quite possibly the best around this area in general. Staff working was very friendly, helpful, and quick. The place is clean and well organized. I don't often pizza places but I will surely be back again

There's two kinds of pizza joints in New York. Pizza Fam, and the rest. If your local pizzeria does not feel like an extension of your family, feeding you with the most delicious and authentic Italian dishes, then they are failures.

Luckily for us, we have Supreme's. Everything that comes out of their ovens and kitchen is nothing short of their name, Supreme.

Kenny and his team not only serve up the most delicious food in the neighborhood, they TAKE CARE of the neighborhood too. I've never seen a place support the community like this before and it is inspiring to all.

The food? Look at the pics, need I say more? I've intentionally chosen the most cheesy, oozy, delicious photos out of the 10 bazillion I have taken of my food. I'm not an IG foodie, I'm just amazed how f'n delicious it looks, every time. Consistency, another huge win from Supreme's. You get the same delicious food this Tuesday that you will get next Friday.

Come join the #pizzafam and have a meal at Supreme's. You won't regret it.

I will say the food is fantastic but the people that take the phone calls are not always on top of things. If they would be more on top of things it would be number one. They do make up for there mistakes but it's annoying to deal with.

Supremes was fantastic! They delivered enough delicious pies right on time to 40 15 year old kids. It was delicious. Thank you so much! Highly recommend