Wantagh Inn

Worth the wait The owner escort you to your table. They run this place like a well oil machine. Water, bread, drinks, food and dessert. Everything Delicious. Would go back again without hesitation.

I came here for a party in their upstairs private rooms. The waitresses at the party werent exactly the friendliest. And when I was setting up the place for the party, they have some strict rules to follow for decorating. I understand certain things but it seems like they implemented these rules because they dont want to be bothered with so much cleaning themselves. But it is a party, people are going to want to decorate. The place itself is clean and it seems like its always busy. The parking lot is so small and the street parking is mostly one hour only parking around there. The food that we were served at this place was mediocre. I've had better food at other places. They did give you good choices though to choose from the menu when you are there for a party though, which I did appreciate. Their portion sizes seemed pretty small to me compared to other places that I have been to. Then they put out pitches of soda but the soda tasted flat. Their punch was good though. Also, the party room is upstairs so you would have to walk it, not too sure if they have some kind of small elevator there though since I didn't ask. It didn't look like it to me, but wouldn't hurt to ask. So the question now remains...would I, personally, go back there? Not for a party, I wouldn't but I would go back there to try the actual restaurant by itself just to see if they give me a bigger portion size of food and to try something else on the menu. So yeah, I would give it another shot on it's own but I wouldnt go to another private party here.

Finally got here after seeing it for years! My wife had the salmon, and I had the Jagerschitzel which was delicious! The owner seated us and the service was excellent. We can't wait to go back!

Went here for a party. Food was delicious, staff friendly. Had a good time. Looks like a place I would stop in for a beer on my way home from work.

Food was excellent! Service was good. Place looks wonderful, all decked out for Christmas!