Carnegie Pizza

(5 Reviews)
200 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036, USA

Report Incorrect Data Write a Review


Category: Restaurant,
Address: 200 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036, USA
Zip code: 10036
Opening hours (Edit)
Monday:10:30 AM – 12:00 AM
Tuesday:10:30 AM – 12:00 AM
Wednesday:10:30 AM – 12:00 AM
Thursday:10:30 AM – 1:00 AM
Friday:10:30 AM – 2:00 AM
Saturday:10:30 AM – 2:00 AM
Sunday:11:00 AM – 12:00 AM

Customer Ratings and Reviews

  • Rosemary (nycstylecannoli) on Google

    (September 15, 2021, 9:41 pm)

    Amazing pizza The flavors come through really well. Slices are very generous as one could be a meal. The dough is light and airy, not heavy at all. Dining in person is ideal, but can order to have shipped, makes well at home. Pizza can be frozen to enjoy later. Wonderful pizza spot in New York City 😋

  • Jennifer Bronson Warren on Google

    (September 15, 2021, 12:12 pm)

    Pizza was good!! Service was friendly and they have salads! We sat outside and watched the world pass by. The subway entrance at Times Square is across the street and makes for an easy meal before jumping on the subway.

  • Daniel H on Google

    (September 6, 2021, 4:34 am)

    Had some yummy Sicilian pizza here. They are the thick style of pizza. First day, I got one slice and it tasted very good. It was about $5 a slice, pricey for NYC but hey, it's Times Square and it was thicker. They have an assortment of all types of pizza (thick and thin) and some salads.

    The second day, I got a box of Sicilian pizza. I can't remember how it cost, but it was somewhere around the $30 neighborhood. While still good, I felt the outer dough was softer than the one-slicer, and preferred the slightly hard outer crust of the one-slicer. But still, the pizza in the box was good.

    They have outdoor seating. Good experience to eat pizza outdoors at night in NYC, next to Times Square. Wish they had some condiments out by the outdoor tables.

  • Sean Kalil on Google

    (August 18, 2021, 3:16 pm)

    I visited this place THREE times in 4 days...THREE!! This pizza is to die for. Best I have ever had. Hands down. The crust of both the Sicilian style and the regular style is so good. Just enough crisp, the cheese blend is so delicious and the sauce is amazing. Love, love, love this spot. Can't wait to get back to NYC for it!

  • Carol Alexander on Google

    (July 31, 2021, 12:10 pm)

    Absolutely delicious pizza! Hands down the best I’ve ever had in NYC and I’ve had some amazing pizza before!

    The selection looked to die for so we got a few different ones and had them cut in halves and 4s on the squares to try all and not be too stuffed.

    The spicy pepperoni square pie is literal crack! The crispness of the little slices of pepperoni are heaven. The vodka pie slice was soooo good. The grandma was perfect 😍 and the white Square pie was the best best best I’ve ever had!!

    Sad we didn’t get any pictures before inhaling it all but we just couldn’t resist not tearing right into it!

    I absolutely loved this place! We definitely will be back next time we go to the city.

Write a Review

Photos of Carnegie Pizza

Submit a review for Carnegie Pizza

Your rating *
Your review (Be as detailed as possible) *
(100 Character minimum)

Tips for writing a great review:
  1. Be specific about your experience and the services that were provided.
  2. Be truthful - this review will help other consumers as well as the business.
  3. Be polite - give feedback in a constructive way.