Casa Antica

We had a confirmed reservation for 9 people. We arrived on time but were told our table had been mistakenly given to someone else. We had to wait almost an hour to get our table that was set up for us. When I spoke to the manager and asked what compensation we would get, she replied, “ I know you come here often and we usually don’t do this but we will give you dessert on the house. “ She added that we could have gone outside to eat. No. The people who took our table could have gone outside!!! We waited almost an hour for our food. The group enjoyed their food but certainly not the service. Three small desserts to be shared between 9 of us was our compensation. Very embarrassing for me!!

This is authentic italian fare! The owner routinely goes to Italy for ingredients. Amazing!

Starting with the bread basket and dips to dessert it was a wonderful experience. The food and service here were high quality. Rustic atmosphere. Outside patio too with live music. Try it. You won't be disappointed.

Definitely one of the best authentic Italian restaurants in WNY. Service was warm, quick and entertaining. The food was spot on and an absolute culinary delight. I highly recommend Casa Antica for a great romantic date night.

My husband and I decided to grab a bite to eat with friends after a long exhausting day. We had to wait a while but it was expected as we did not have a reservation. We sat down and received fresh water right away. Our server (Cristina) was very kind and hilariously witty. It was terribly busy and yet she made it look effortless. I’m assuming she’s been in this line of work for a while, as she was very proficient. She told us the specials and recommended her favorite (lobster/scallops/shrimp scampi). Can I just say, that it was by FAR one of the best dishes Ive had in a long time. Worth the wait! I will add that the food took longer than expected but our server was very attentive, and kept us happy with full drinks and a delightful bread spread. The atmosphere was inviting and has one of the best patios in Lewiston and also maybe one of the only places with an outdoor side bar. Very charming. Ive been recommending this place every chance i get, and will be returning as soon as Im in the area. Very impressed.