Nonna's Pizza

They're official. This pizza is loaded with fresh and tasty ingredients. Even better the staff is friendly and down to earth.

We can’t decide if the service or the food was more spectacular. We found this place by accident and it ended up being a highlight of our trip. Thank you so much for all you do here.

First time I went there, a few weeks ago, there was an argument going on between the men who were doing the deliveries while I was in there trying to order with my child. My little one was nervous and asked to stay in the car cuz it was getting really really loud in there between them. I ordered and to my surprise the pizza was good ????. Today I went again. The men who do the deliveries, they are all over the place and take up much of the counter space that is intended for the customers who are coming in to order or pick up. I ordered a sicilian slice and a regular slice. I did not look at my order before leaving the store. I get in my car drive off, about five to six blocks later I opened up the box and there is a triangular Sicilian slice. Must have been the first time I've ever seen a triangular Sicilian slice. My little one wasn't too happy about it but I decided it wasn't worth my time to go back and have it changed. Although I must say the pizza is still pretty good but I'll think I'll have to skip it next time and find another spot to go to.

Hands down, one of the best pies on SI. Always a consistently good, reliable product. Been ordering from here for years. The community organization I belong to, orders from here for all their functions.

One of the most underrated pizza places, right by the Great Kills SIR platform (hint). A reasonably busy place, but with fast service. Make sure to double check your order, for the staff is busy as well. That being said, the food quality is very high, with a great price to quality ratio. Absolutely recommended.