Bagels By the Bay

Some of the best bagels we’ve had served by friendly people. Glad we’re taking half a dozen home.

Great authentic handmade bagels. If you want a REAL New York bagel, this is your place.

Small place, with small variety of delicious, good quality bagels. Loved their cheddar cheese/jalapeño bagel with egg and cheese. And got rainbow colored bagel with cinnamon/raisin/walnut cream cheese for my daughter and she devoured it. Not the first time here, but it's always a treat ❤️

My coworker told me bout the place.. The staff was very nice n attentive.. however I ordered an egg n cheese on a bagel w/ coffee just to try their food for the first time. This very nice looking gentleman hands me my food n as I'm off to eat my meal.. The egg peel/shell is in my bkfast sandwich. I had to spit out about 3 bites or so of my food cause I didn't wanna dig through it. Guess I won't be going back there again..

Bagels By The Bay has outdone the entirety of NY bagels, and dare I say God, with their perfection. These bagels will change your life. I grew up in NY - I've had all the bagels. I've since moved out of NY, and for 6 years now I cannot TELL you how often I think of these particular bagels. I've had literal dreams of these bagels. Wake yourself up at 5:00 if you have to. Get there exactly when they open, and experience the joy of a warm Bagel by the Bay. I am currently sitting at my desk, hundreds of miles away, eating a sad grocery store bagel. Please, if you have the opportunity to visit this wonderful place, know that I am shedding a tear of joy on your behalf.