Stefano's of Staten Island

I’ve been in the neighborhood for over 25 years so I’ve seen this place turn over owners multiple times. I always gave the new owners a chance and it has always been mediocre. Finally we have a SOLID neighborhood pizza joint.
So far we ordered two times; first order was a plain large pie, Buffalo chicken pie and a chicken roll. All three were really good. Second order was a Sicilian and a personal chicken Caesar pie which was again, really good.
Prices are more than fair, delivery was on time and they payed attention to the delivery instructions I left. I don’t have anything bad to say. Keep up the great work.

Great pies! 😋

Don't be fooled....this place is SO MUCH MORE than just a pizzeria. Sure the pizza is absolutely delicious...but I just finished eating their seafood combo and just....wow. That's literally all I can say. Wow. Wow. Wow. It's a must try for any seafood lover. Oh and the staff is so friendly! Overall fantastic experience. I was coming from Brooklyn visiting friends. It's about 30 minutes from me but I will most definitely be stopping by again.

I came to visit family and we order a pie 1/2 sausage on Tuesday and wowwwwwwwwwww, trust me it's one of the most delicious pizza I ever had, the touch on the sauce its almost glorious, the cheese it's perfectly melted and mixed with the sauce, beside the amazing crunchy crust , if it was a contest, 1 to 10 they deserve a 100, you people from staten island need to check this place...

Their Sicilian pizza is delicious! The crust is not too thick and the sauce really has a distinct flavor. They put pride in their food and it really shows. Everything I order from here is really good. My family always looks forward to ordering from here. Highly recommend this place.