Pizza Village

Nice place to have a slice or two. Staff was friendly and helpful. They had a special of 4 slices (pepperoni or meatball) for $15. Might seem pricey, but they were fairly thick slices with a generous amount of toppings.

The pizza in the restaurant is the best pizza because the pizza i ate was sooooo yummy. I will make this pizza restaurant my favorite excellent pizza restaurant ever

AMAZING!! Food and GREAT staff! Me and my father came today and got chicken Alfredo and their shrimp and broccoli Alfredo and I was definitely impressed! I’m a very picky eater and haven’t been able to find good Alfredo in years and I definitely found my new go to place! My dads shrimp Alfredo was packed with shrimp he was so happy and it tasted delicious! The portions are huge and the prices are better than reasonable! Everyone was so friendly and polite. Definitely recommend anyone going to Montauk and wants some amazing food to stop in! I will be back soon!

Great food and service here. They wherever busy and I see why. The pizza was as outstanding . We tried several appetizers and salads and they were all very good and reasonably priced. Highly recommend.

If you are craving pizza in Montauk, nothing should stop you from going to Pizza Village. It has been a Montauk staple for longer than I've been alive, while all the other pizza places have turned over. Having lived various places now, and tasted a lot of pizza, I can say their's is solid but not exceptional for Long Island (which has some of the best pizza in the country) and excellent when compared to the other parts of the state/country I've eaten pizza in. Their crust has a nice chew, their cheese is decent quality, but I think their sauce on the regular pie lacks. I found the sauce on their Sicilian to be much better (and found their Sicilian to be as good as almost any I've had).

My favorite is always a plain cheese, so I can't talk too much about the types of pies, but I think their meat pies use decent quality meat. My family really likes their white pie with broccoli. I think they used to spread the ricotta like sauce, which I thought was good. Now the ricotta is placed in clumps, which I don't personally love.

FYI, you can only sit in the dinning room if you order a whole pie (or non-pizza food, I assume). There are benches outside, if you want a slice. Usually I am either picking it up to take to my parent's or walking around town anyway, so this hasn't bothered me.