Nicky's On the Bay

We had the place to ourselves for a holiday party. Really enjoyed the bbq chicken pizza and prime rib. Right by the water which is cool to see boats pull up and moor up by the side. The bar seemed pretty standard, but the employees were super nice. The only draw back was the cold. Sitting on the side that faces the large windows is still pretty cold even with the heat indoors at full blast. I should mention it was night time... We had to eat at the bar on the side which faces the kitchen to keep warm... it was just super cold that night. Somewhere around 20 degrees with winds. But nice either way.

Love coming here with my family in the summer. My grandfather used to go to Nicky's a lot and was good friends with him. Since my grandfather passed, we eat at Nicky's in remembrance of my grandfather. The food is GREAT and the service is very good as well

My nephew's wedding was here. The staff was very helpful and friendly. Great service! Great food! Great atmosphere! Beautiful deck outside with great views. Definitely going back!

I agree it's pricey. We had the pleasure of being helped by Steve. He was amazing, attentive and funny. We had that calamari. It was cooked perfectly. The raw bar combo was fresh, the mussels in wine and garlic butter were really good.

Food is not bad, no gluten free menu, but I was able to find something to order and I didn't get sick. Others in my group enjoyed theirs more. Prices are high, you're really paying for the location and the view. Dress in layers if you want to sit outside, it can get windy.