Renzo's

Great food, awesome service fair pricing. Definitely the most underrated Pizzeria on the south shore.

I just left this wonderful establishment.. and this place has THEEE BEST PIZZA IN LONG ISLAND!!!

Great Pizza but also other Italian Pizza like foods , plenty of parking, open till past 8pm so grab supper and enjoy yourself either as take out or eating there.

We love renzos! The people are amazing there is always something awesome to try. They are always trying new combos along with the classics. The best specialty slices are penne ala vodka, white with broccoli, eggplant parmesan and buffalo chicken with a side of ranch!! They also have this roll thing if you can get one they only make a few a day it's grilled chicken lettuce onion or no onion a combo of fresh mozzarella and shredded mozzarella with a ceasar dressing rolled up in thin pizza dough! It is to die for! I pass at least six other pizza places to go here. Highly recommend.

It took 2 days to eat the pie :). It was delicious and the amount you get for the price is amazing. My family came from Florida and wanted real NY pizza. The best pizza out here in East Islip area. The staff was also very friendly. I'm glad we found this hidden jewel.