Maguire's

We went here last night for the 1st time, But not the last time Myself and 10 yes 10 other nurse came to celebrate 2 birthdays, We all had the specials Lobster or prime rib It was GREAT! My friends can’t stop talking about the good food we had everything was delicious and our waiter and bus staf. Were excellent

Asked for a table outside along the rail. Hostess advised me that 4 adults cannot sit at any of the empty tables set for 6! Asked to sw the Mgr & was told he's too busy! Went inside asked the Mgr, who reluctantly, let us sit at a table along the rail! Our waitress saved the day. We rec'd 5 star service from her and the rest of the wait staff. Food was expensive, crab legs were $58! A rocket fuel drink was half the price at the bar than what we were charged at the table! Total bill was $296 + a very generous tip. I think we spent more than other tables of 6 that were drinking soda & only having appetizers. Overall food was good.

Service was rushed but decent. The clam chowder was good and the scallops and shrimp were served in a pineapple, which was both amusing and quite good. The curry was as hot as half and half, but simultaneously decent.

A Local Favorite, Maguire's is an impressive joint. With a beautiful view of the great south bay, wonderful nautical atmosphere, and service that always impresses, It is an amazing place. My personal favorite is there Lobster Roll and Long Island Steamers, but everything else on the menu makes you jump for joy. Head over to Maguires for an awesome time.

We were here in the off season but absolutely loved the location, the service and the food. The cocktails were outstanding as well. The steak and horseradish mashed potatoes were fantastic and my sister got some kind of pasta which she said was great. View at sunset is killer. We sat outside on the patio and were in heaven!