Neversink General Store

I am a wedding planner, so naturally, I deal with a lot of caterers. I first tasted, Jaime at Neversink General Stores, food in 2018.. although there were logistical issues with them then, the food was so good, I wanted it for my wedding. A whole year later, I got engaged and started to plan. I thought a year later that the logistical issues would be figured out by then so I gave them a shot. Although again, the food was amazing, Jaime and Neversink General Store did figure out their logistics. They tried getting me to pay for them to come back and pick up their rentals, on THE DAY OF MY WEDDING, never saying anything before that, forgot food, rude delivery people, dirty tablecloths, and more. When I spoke to Jaime he assured he wanted me to be happy, as the bride, and let me know he would send a check for some money back per person. That was 3 months ago. I have emailed him countless times, he has stopped responding. If he would've sent the money (which wasn't about the money, it was the principle of the matter) i would've tried using him again on a private party, but now I won't and I will not recommend him to any of my couples in the future. It is completely unprofessional to tell someone, who paid you 4 GRAND to, that you are going to do something, and then not even have the decency to email them back .This place could be great, because again, their food is so good, but save yourself the aggravation and go somewhere where the food is good AND they honor what they say they're going to do.

UPDATE: After writing this review, I did receive an email back and a check in the mail - not sure if it's coincidence, or they saw the review, but I did receive what I was told I would.

Well I have to say chef Jamie outdid himself as usual and prepared my holiday dinner... his brisket was delish as was the chicken franchise. Potatoes , carrots who knew!!!thank u Jamie u made my holiday easy and therefore more enjoyable... happy new year

The Neversink General Store provided a mobile catering trailer, served gourmet tacos to our crowd of 250+ Jeep Jamboree participants on registration night. We gave them less than 24 hrs notice but their team pulled it off amazingly. I'd highly recommend them for sure!

It was my first time visit there and it was pleasant. Everyone was friendly and i enjoyed the sandwich and fries that I bought for lunch ????. I would definitely visit again.

Definitely not your average General Store. Daily specials (?) made by one or more very qualified chef's. I ate there almost daily for a week. This is a well run business that is obviously customer focused and it shows!